Byproduct to Benefit - Baba Brinkman

What’s the original origin of religion?

Is it teleology?

Agency detection?

Theory of mind, or anthropomorphism?

Those are byproducts of common social cognition

So there was no benefit, huh?

No function?

Just a random bunch of intuitions and hunches

Just mental eruptions in a population of primates

Tryin' to keep track of each others' changeable mind states

Minds play tricks like Scarface and Bushwick

They see intentions in every rustle of bushes

But so what if religion started kinda random

Nothin' adaptive about it,

just a spandrel?

That doesn’t mean it stayed that way,

it could’ve taken

A turn for the beneficial and become an adaptation

That’s what happened to feathers,

birds can fly and soar

Even if their descended from a terrestrial dinosaur

But Jurassic World lost the plot a bit

It pissed off a whole lot of palaeontologists

‘Cause raptors had feathers,

the question is why

Would evolution produce a feather that can’t fly?

Here’s a toast to the scavengers

Leveraging advantages

Makin' something outta nothin'

Byproducts into benefits

Here’s a toast to survivors

To the dumpster divers

Makin' beauty out of blemishes

Byproducts into benefits

Take a look at a flock of velociraptors

They can’t fly but feathers are also attractive

So they’re good for displays and mating dances

And they’re fuzzy,

so there’s an insulation factor

How else you gonna to keep a tyrannosaur warm in a rain storm?

That’s how the feather was formed

But dinosaurs ran into an asteroid apocalypse

A few survivors descended from archaeopteryx

A new function for the feather was found

Propelling an organism across the ground

Mutations accumulated and spread them flatter

Gradually makin' them more aerodynamic

And dinosaurs survived;

they recolonized the earth

Today we know them as «birds»

Okay, dinosaurs didn’t make it, but their descendants did

They turned a byproduct into a benefit

Here’s a toast to the scavengers

Leveraging advantages

Makin' something outta nothin'

Byproducts into benefits

Here’s a toast to survivors

To the dumpster divers

Makin' beauty out of blemishes

Byproducts into benefits

The original origins of religion

A side effect of social cognition

An imaginary population of intuitions

Ancestors, gods and apparitions

But populations change, they’re not static

They fluctuate like soft plastic

Some gods proliferate, others fade away

Like Poseidon, who nobody prays to today

You’re a Poseidon atheist, admit it

And you’re comfortable with it, which makes you a militant

Poseidon atheist — «Poseidon theology»

Used to be huge, but now we call it «oceanography»

Beliefs change and impact behaviour

They spread from head to head through oral labia

So what’s religion, a byproduct or benefit?

Well that depends on what you spread with it

Here’s a toast to the scavengers

Leveraging advantages

Makin' something outta nothin'

Byproducts into benefits

Here’s a toast to survivors

To the dumpster divers

Makin' beauty out of blemishes

Byproducts into benefits